It has been criticized by some as an undemocratic anachronism, but praised by others as a pillar of political stability and american federalism. The 2015 winter with the writers season kicked off a day early last week with. The electoral college facilitates the joining of the states in union. The amendment was proposed by the congress on december 9, 1803, and was ratified by the requisite threefourths of state. A new push to use student projects in college admissions. Educationally speaking, the harvard of 2015 looks substantially like the. By definition of how the system works, the winning candidate won.
Circuit court of appeals at denver ruled 21 this week that the electoral college system established by article ii and the 12th amendment of the u. The electoral college encourages the 2 party system, because people think they have to vote for the lesser evil in order for their vote to count. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. Warren calls for eliminating the electoral college.
Amsco united states history 2015 edition, chapter 6 the constitution and the new republic, 17871800. Supporters say it will bring fairness to national elections, while critics warn it could lead to violence. Higher education cant solve inequality, but the debate about free college tuition does something extremely valuable. We should preserve the electoral college, but lower by two the number of electors allocated to every state. No state would have signed on to a system that stripped them of any chance of influence, and no state should want that now. A number of states want to abolish the electoral college in favor of the popular vote. Taming the electoral college explores poorly understood aspects of the electoral college, including two possibilities in particular that could pose the most serious danger for american democracy. Herrings apush homework the week of 103107 learn with flashcards, games, and more for free.
Open book club, discuss what you are currently reading. Although groups like the league of women voters have long supported the abolition of the electoral college, 1 the protracted proceedings in florida as well as the apparent disparity between the popular and the electoral college vote have further fueled calls to abolish the electoral college. The story of the electoral college is also one of slaveryan institution central to the founding of american democracy. The twelfth amendment amendment xii to the united states constitution provides the procedure for electing the president and vice president. When applied on a national scale, such as the election of a countrys leader, the popular vote can on occasion run counter to the electoral colleges vote, and for this reason there are some who feel that the system is a distortion of true democracy. The most basic reason that the founders invented the electoral college was that the convention was deadlocked on simpler schemes like direct election and choice by congress, and thus invented a.
Click to read contending arguments from matt bruenig and mike konczal. Us news is a recognized leader in college, grad school, hospital, mutual fund, and car rankings. Critics urge a replacement of the electoral college with a straightforward. The system can ignore the wishes of a general membership whose thinking may not be considered.
I really liked this book because i am a teacher and although i went to college. New americas kevin carey answers questions about his new book, the. Student groups using election to push for changes to post. Shane frazier started this petition to united states congress. Discover delightful childrens books with prime book box, a subscription that delivers new books every 1, 2, or 3 months new customers. End it, mend it or leave the electoral college system alone. The system was a bad idea that quickly went haywire.
The electoral college system has proved to be durable. With the electoral college, the voting power of the people has been diluted and unequally distributed, when each citizens vote should hold equal weight and significance for the sake of democracy. Reforming the electoral college is the subject of another recent crs report, electoral college reform. Electoral college vote updates and voting schedule cbs news. A critical analysis john heyrman department of political science berea college email. It replaced the procedure provided in article ii, section 1, clause 3, by which the electoral college originally functioned. Central college news page 5 news and information from.
Series of essays, later published as a book, written by james madison, alexander hamilton, and john jay. Electoral college foes continue push to make popular vote. Those students must request assistance by utilizing this e. The 56th meeting of the north carolina electoral college was held on dec. Donald trump won the electoral college to become president in 2016, although hillary clinton won the popular vote.
Reviewed in the united kingdom on january 11, 2015. That happened first in 1800, when a mixup about electors threw the presidential vote into the house, sparking 35 ballots over a weekand. Jesse wegmans let the people pick the president is a readable account of how the electoral college distorts our political system. Currently, each state gets a number of electors equivalent to the number of its members of the. The electoral college has the effect of making voting in non marginal states pointless. The full text of the press release is below the fold. This is an excerpt from my chapter on the electoral college and 2016, contained in the forthcoming anthology from rowman and littlefield, the surge. The author whose novel inspired the film precious discusses. Central college honored earl simmelink, a longtime and generous donor to the college, by naming the atrium in graham conference center in his honor. Track elected officials, research health conditions, and find news you can use in politics. Supreme court ruled that primary candidates for party electors can be required to. Rob richie and john samples about why the electoral college was created and how it influences the nature and strategy of elections.
Electoral colleges faithless electors fail to stop trump but land democratic blow at least nine electors attempted to cast a vote against the candidate they were mandated to support, drawing. Volume 4, issue 3 should the electoral college count. This report focuses on the institutions and procedures. The academy award winning film is based on her new york times bestselling novel push. Seven proposals to reform the electoral college system have been introduced to date in the 107th congress. Constitution allows presidential electors to vote against the candidate the popular vote in their state commits them to vote for. Post by janet napolitano, the university of california systems president. The idea is to create a shared system that enables quick recognition of project quality, the way 4s or 5s on advanced placement. The national popular vote plan to bypass the electoral college. The framers of the constitution supported the electoral college system for a variety of reasons, but none of those reasons included thwarting the public will. Electoral colleges faithless electors fail to stop. Central college honors longtime donor with earl simmelink atrium. A new poll from morning consultpolitico found that 46% of voters say the electoral college should be replaced by a national popular vote. College university press releases and news stories from 247 press release.
These are, first, determination of the president by faithless electors who ignore the popular vote in their states, and, second, choice of the president in the house of representatives, which is. History electoral system is the electoral college fair or unfair. Selingo presents a picture of how he sees the higher education system in the u. A tv monitor shows the third presidential debate in 2016. Electoral college john jay college of criminal justice. In part the gpbc is concerned about the impact of the electoral college on minority and smaller party voters.
Kevin carey talks about his new book, the end of college. In the wake of hillary clintons popular vote victory but electoral vote loss, some have called for the end of the electoral college which could significantly change how candidates campaign. Electoral college news, video and community from msnbc. Senator durbin and representative lahood called for a constitutional amendment to abolish the electoral college, saying it was outdated and did not let the will of the voter prevail in presidential. But the way this system treats voters in the remaining states is not wellunderstood.
The bulk of the new nations citizenry resided in cities like. Alexander hamilton, the founding father least enamored with the merits of democracy, supported direct popular election of the president at the constitutional convention in 1787. By law, the electoral commission must consider the wording of referendum questions and report our views on their intelligibility as soon as is reasonably. It reintroduces the concept of public good to education discourse.
Abdul jones, who is left to navigate the foster system at a young age. On 5 th july 2015 the greek electorate went to the polls to vote on the following referendum question it would be safe to say that in the uk, this 74word question would not have passed our referendum question intelligibility test. Yesterday the green party black caucus issued a press release addressing a letter of protest they sent to attorney general eric holder. Changing the electoral college system presents several options, sometimes characterized as. I had used this book when my son and daughter were going to college 20 years ago and it was very informative. The head of one of the countrys largest groups representing college and university students says her organization is looking for federal parties to.
Twelfth amendment to the united states constitution. As blue states push to abolish electoral college, critics. Her novel push, won the bookofthemonth club stephen crane award for first fiction, the black caucus of the american library associations first novelist. A politician in the electoral college should not have more say on who becomes the president of our nation than the average citizen.
1527 550 1332 1359 556 433 627 406 1449 1065 1011 1070 886 236 391 830 64 1524 1417 185 1372 315 676 1426 475 1288 1140 23 755 895 855 148 1545 1372 287 427 582 884 683 1432 721 1396 250 1164 320 174 724 1378 289 1027